Reza Bastani Namaghi
Back to Home
A Critical Review of the Recent Resolutions by the Regulatory Commission and the Council of Ministers Regarding the Artificial Intelligence Services License

A Critical Review of the Recent Resolutions by the Regulatory Commission and the Council of Ministers Regarding the Artificial Intelligence Services License

I was recently drafting a research report for the Legal Commission of the Chamber of Commerce regarding the new resolution by the Communications Regulatory Commission and the subsequent decree by the Council of Ministers (concerning the AI Services License or AISP). These resolutions seem alarming; in that the regulatory body and the government have designed the heavy obligations of major telecommunication operators for the nascent and agile ecosystem of artificial intelligence.

When conditions such as providing a minimum of 200 PetaFLOPS of processing power, paying a 50 billion Toman initial licensing fee, submitting a 100 billion Toman bank guarantee (massive, prohibitive sums in the local economic context that effectively act as an insurmountable barrier to entry for the private tech sector), and surrendering 3% of gross annual revenue as the government's share are included in these regulations, a clear message is sent to the market: the entry of startups and small to medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) into this field is prohibited.

From a legal perspective, this method of regulation has several fundamental flaws:

First, the Regulatory Commission, whose inherent duty is the regulation of physical and telecommunication networks, has effectively exceeded its legal authority by entering the software and algorithm processing layer.

Second, the Council of Ministers, by incorrectly invoking a law originally passed for physical telecommunication networks, has imposed a revenue share on software earnings; this action, without explicit authorization from the legislature, is a clear instance of bypassing Articles 51 and 53 of the Constitution, which establish the principle of legality in taxation—meaning no government fee can be levied without direct parliamentary legislation.

Third, this magnitude of financial and hardware barriers is in blatant contradiction with the Law on Implementation of the General Policies of Article 44—Iran's privatization laws designed to prevent monopolies and encourage private sector competition—and the Law on Support of Knowledge-Based Companies. The result of this approach will be the creation of a dangerous monopoly for a few "quasi-governmental" companies (entities that are ostensibly privatized but remain under the heavy influence of state or military-affiliated organizations) or macro-capitalists, who usually, by receiving massive loans and numerous benefits, ultimately produce outputs with very low efficiency and high costs that will not be able to compete with quality products.

The development of artificial intelligence does not occur through mandates and the creation of heavy financial barriers. With this trajectory, not only will this technology not be promoted in the country, but the sector will suffer even more damage. In my opinion, before irreparable harm is inflicted on this ecosystem, we have no choice but to pursue the annulment of these resolutions through the Court of Administrative Justice (the highest administrative tribunal where citizens can sue to annul illegal government regulations), the Parliamentary Board for the Adaptation of Government Resolutions (an oversight committee ensuring cabinet decrees do not violate parliamentary laws), the Competition Council, and the Deregulation Board.

Written by Reza Bastani Namaghi
Download Attached File
Previous Post Managing PDF Files Without Installing Software Next Post Eviction from Bank-Mortgaged Properties and the Legal Status of the Tenant